Irony India Claims To Run Bullet Train But Unable To Control Normal Train Accidents

In the vast expanse of India, the railway network stands as a testament to the nation’s industrial might and its critical role in connecting millions. However, beneath the facade of progress lies a crumbling system plagued by inefficiency, negligence, and a shocking frequency of accidents that claim lives with disturbing regularity. The irony of India’s ambition to introduce bullet trains, while failing to ensure the safety of its conventional rail services, underscores a stark reality: the Indian Railways is in dire straits, and the Ministry of Railways has failed to address its deep-seated issues.

A Legacy of Accidents and Mismanagement

The Indian Railways, one of the world’s largest railway networks, has been marred by a series of catastrophic accidents. Despite advancements in technology and infrastructure, the frequency of these accidents reveals a persistent neglect of passenger safety and operational integrity.

Recent Accidents: A Grim Timeline

1. Odisha Train Collision (June 2023): A horrifying collision involving the Coromandel Express and the Yeshvantpur-Howrah Express in Balasore resulted in the deaths of nearly 300 passengers and injured over 1,000. The tragedy exposed glaring lapses in signal management and emergency response protocols.
2. Amritsar Train Tragedy (October 2018): During a Dussehra celebration, a speeding train ran over a crowd gathered on the tracks, killing over 60 people. The incident highlighted the reckless disregard for safety regulations and the absence of adequate crowd control measures.
3. Kalinga Utkal Express Derailment (August 2017): The derailment of the Kalinga Utkal Express in Uttar Pradesh resulted in 23 fatalities and over 150 injuries. Subsequent investigations revealed serious lapses in track maintenance and communication failures among railway staff.
4. Indore-Patna Express Derailment (November 2016): One of the deadliest accidents in recent history, the derailment of the Indore-Patna Express in Kanpur claimed 150 lives. Investigations pointed to defective tracks and poor maintenance practices as primary causes.

The Irony of Bullet Train Ambitions

While India aspires to join the elite club of nations boasting high-speed bullet trains, the reality on the ground is far more sobering. The introduction of the Mumbai-Ahmedabad bullet train project, a venture costing an estimated ₹1.1 trillion ($15 billion), seems incongruent with the everyday struggles faced by the Indian Railways. Critics argue that this project is a misallocation of resources in a country where the fundamental safety and efficiency of regular train services remain grossly inadequate.

A Ministerial Failure

The Railway Ministry, under the leadership of various ministers, has repeatedly failed to implement comprehensive safety measures. Despite numerous committees and recommendations, the execution remains lackluster. The Kakodkar Committee, established in 2012, made 106 recommendations to improve railway safety, yet only a fraction have been implemented to date.

Underfunding and Misallocation

The Indian Railways operates under severe financial constraints, with a significant portion of its budget allocated to new projects rather than upgrading existing infrastructure. In the 2023-24 budget, ₹2.40 lakh crore ($32 billion) was earmarked for capital expenditure, but the allocation for safety-related upgrades and maintenance remains disproportionately low. This imbalance reflects a systemic failure to prioritize passenger safety over expansion ambitions.

Recent Mishaps and Negligence

1. Unmanned Level Crossings: Despite numerous fatalities, unmanned level crossings remain a significant hazard. As of 2023, there are still hundreds of such crossings, each posing a lethal threat to unsuspecting travelers.
2. Poor Track Maintenance: Many of the recent accidents have been attributed to defective tracks and inadequate maintenance. The Railway Board’s own reports highlight that over 4,500 km of tracks are overdue for renewal.
3. Outdated Signaling Systems: The antiquated signaling systems in place across much of the network contribute to frequent accidents. Modernization efforts have been slow and insufficient.

List of Train Accidents in India (2014-2024) and Their Death Records

2023

1. Odisha Train Collision (June 2023)
   • Location: Balasore, Odisha
   • Death Toll: 300
   • Injuries: 1,000+

2022

2. Jalpaiguri Train Derailment (January 2022)
   • Location: Jalpaiguri, West Bengal
   • Death Toll: 9
   • Injuries: 45

2021

3. Bikaner-Guwahati Express Derailment (January 2021)
   • Location: West Bengal
   • Death Toll: 9
   • Injuries: 36

2020

4. Aurangabad Train Accident (May 2020)
   • Location: Aurangabad, Maharashtra
   • Death Toll: 16
   • Injuries: 0

2019

5. Seemanchal Express Derailment (February 2019)
   • Location: Vaishali, Bihar
   • Death Toll: 7
   • Injuries: 29

2018

6. Amritsar Train Tragedy (October 2018)
   • Location: Amritsar, Punjab
   • Death Toll: 60+
   • Injuries: 50+
7. Dussehra Train Accident (October 2018)
   • Location: Amritsar, Punjab
   • Death Toll: 61
   • Injuries: 143
8. Kalka Mail Derailment (October 2018)
   • Location: Uttar Pradesh
   • Death Toll: 0
   • Injuries: 10

2017

9. Kalinga Utkal Express Derailment (August 2017)
   • Location: Muzaffarnagar, Uttar Pradesh
   • Death Toll: 23
   • Injuries: 150+
10. Mahakaushal Express Derailment (March 2017)
    • Location: Uttar Pradesh
    • Death Toll: 0
    • Injuries: 52

2016

11. Indore-Patna Express Derailment (November 2016)
    • Location: Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh
    • Death Toll: 150
    • Injuries: 150+
12. Pukhrayan Train Derailment (November 2016)
    • Location: Kanpur Dehat, Uttar Pradesh
    • Death Toll: 150+
    • Injuries: 200+

2015

13. Hirakhand Express Derailment (January 2017)
    • Location: Andhra Pradesh
    • Death Toll: 41
    • Injuries: 68
14. Dehradun-Varanasi Janata Express Derailment (March 2015)
    • Location: Uttar Pradesh
    • Death Toll: 34
    • Injuries: 150+

2014

15. Dibrugarh Rajdhani Express Derailment (June 2014)
    • Location: Bihar
    • Death Toll: 4
    • Injuries: 8
16. Maharashtra Train Derailment (May 2014)
    • Location: Maharashtra
    • Death Toll: 20
    • Injuries: 100+

Conclusion

The Indian Railways, once a symbol of national pride, now stands as a stark reminder of governmental negligence and misplaced priorities. The contrast between the gleaming promise of bullet trains and the harsh reality of frequent, preventable train accidents is a damning indictment of the current administration’s failure to ensure basic safety and efficiency. The Ministry of Railways must urgently refocus its efforts on modernizing and maintaining the existing rail infrastructure, implementing safety recommendations, and prioritizing the lives of the millions who depend on this critical mode of transport. Until these systemic issues are addressed, the tragic cycle of accidents and loss will continue, tarnishing India’s aspirations of becoming a global leader in rail transport.